Junior year will feel very empty next year without a class like sophomore history. Not only did we have the opportunity to learn an incredible amount of material in a year's time, we learned about HOW to learn, study, and analyze (and have fun too!). After this year I know what it means to be a historian. I learned how to prepare an argument and how to develop a strong idea and eventually a thesis based on evidence that we have seen throughout history. History is not about learning facts and events that have occurred in the modern world, but rather seeing a connection between the way things happened. This notion was made clear to me this year. I learned that two abstract ideas that seem completely unrelated at the surface, for a completely random example, the Carolands Mansion in Hillsborough and the Terracotta Warriors in Xian China, can be connected to each other so strongly...even strongly enough to write ten pages about! I will do my best to take the things that I learned to be so fun about history with me next year and throughout the rest of my historical career. Thank you Mama Pugs for the tremendous year you have given us! Please come back to your true passion of teaching history after next year as you are fed up with teaching just the boring English for an entire year.
Wednesday, July 21, 2010
Wednesday, June 9, 2010
Connection Webs
If I had to choose the single most important thing that I learned this year, I think the connection webs can best summarize it. Beyond the factual connections, the connection webs that we constructed at various points throughout the year and on both of our finals encouraged us to look for patterns throughout history. By creating these connections between ostensibly unrelated historical events, I found that history does repeat itself. Similarly, in the extremism essay, I synthesized knowledge of various extremist groups and interpreted the factors that allowed them to become so popular, finding that each of the distinct events were spurred on by equally miserable circumstances. Also, what's that other word we mentioned this year? Nationalism, maybe? The idea of finding connections throughout history is useful in explaining why our world has become the way it is today, but the most compelling part is that this knowledge can be used to relate our understanding of common historical themes to the modern world and current events so that we can influence the shape of the future.
Monday, June 7, 2010
SOAPS, SPECS and gutting
The single important thing I learned this year in Modern World History was how to organize information. SOAPS, SPECS and learning how to gut a book were concrete skills that I can continue to utilize in my studies. I'm not an abstract thinker or a very creative person so I need structure when I work. I would get stressed out when I had a source because I didn't know what to do with it. I would just annotate and take notes but couldn't glean the most important info. SOAPS and SPECS help me identify background info on the source and where the argument is coming from. When doing research I would completely avoid books because I didn't know the most effective way to extract information. I thought that you had to read the entire book, which was more time than I wanted to dedicate to my research. But now I know the most efficient way to use a book in research and am not limited to just the internet any more.
Sunday, June 6, 2010
Iran and Algeria: Same Vibration
SKIM the thesis, timeline, and SPECS table of the three other revolutionary groups. CHOOSE one of the revolutions and WRITE a comparison between it and the revolution you researched in class. POST this paragraph to the blog with the LABEL: Your first name, late 20th revs - 3
The Iranian Revolution and the Algerian Revolution had about the same amount of success: almost none. While the two revolutions differed in many ways, the outcomes were very similar, both literally and on a more analytical level.
While the Algerians were rebelling against their French colonizers, and the Iranians were rebelling against people of the same original nationality, both countries went from a Westernized government to a government controlled in some part by Islamic groups. In both cases, power changed hands many times, making the government very inconsistent and unstable. In Iran, people still fear the government to the point of completely losing hope. In Algeria, there has relatively recently been very large amounts of violence, so everything is still in turmoil.
Perhaps one of the largest indicators of failure is the collapse of both countries' economies. While an economic failure may seems small compared to massacres and violence, it can have much more devastating long-term effects. In Algeria, people are trying to escape their failed economy, only to be sent back home by their government. Violence can change governments very quickly, but a bad economy can ruin even the best.
The Iranian Revolution and the Algerian Revolution had about the same amount of success: almost none. While the two revolutions differed in many ways, the outcomes were very similar, both literally and on a more analytical level.
While the Algerians were rebelling against their French colonizers, and the Iranians were rebelling against people of the same original nationality, both countries went from a Westernized government to a government controlled in some part by Islamic groups. In both cases, power changed hands many times, making the government very inconsistent and unstable. In Iran, people still fear the government to the point of completely losing hope. In Algeria, there has relatively recently been very large amounts of violence, so everything is still in turmoil.
Perhaps one of the largest indicators of failure is the collapse of both countries' economies. While an economic failure may seems small compared to massacres and violence, it can have much more devastating long-term effects. In Algeria, people are trying to escape their failed economy, only to be sent back home by their government. Violence can change governments very quickly, but a bad economy can ruin even the best.
Saturday, June 5, 2010
Cold Rivalries
READ 678-681. WRITE a blog post in which you compare the rivalry of the Cold War (as outlined in the reading and in our in-class work) with other international rivalries we've studied this year.
LABEL: Your first name, cold rivalries
The rivalry of the cold war had many similarities and differences to the more traditional rivalries we studied earlier in the year. The "normal" rivalries typically consisted of dissent between adjacent nations, an arms race of some sort, perhaps a fortification of borders, and maybe even an attack. In this sense, the cold war was both traditional and not at the same time.
As most people know, the cold was was a major nuclear arms race between America and the Soviet Union. This type of arms race leading up t a war is completely normal, but in this case the arms race pretty much was the war. It was this nuclear presence that set the cold war so far apart from others. Because the US and Russia were across the seas from each other, the fortifications occurred in other countries in Europe, which was very unusual. And instead or making defenses for their own country, each side simply pointed progressively more nuclear weapons at the other side. The long range of the weapons was what created and international panic: now even countries on the other side of the world were a serious threat.
The "war" was the result in a difference of two ideals, those of communism and those of capitalism. This kind of cause is normal, although the two sides were not. While sometimes fighting may break out on one side of the argument, the communists weren't even CLOSE to unified, which is highly unusual for a war, and especially ironic, as the point of communism is everyone working together for a better future.
While you could argue that actually engaging is battle is not necessary for war, it seems that a term like "contretemps" may better fit the cold war.
Note: I am not trying to say the cold war wasn't an issue; I understand that it was very close to being World War III, and quite possibly the end of life in Russia and America, but I'm not sure it fits the definition o a war.
LABEL: Your first name, cold rivalries
The rivalry of the cold war had many similarities and differences to the more traditional rivalries we studied earlier in the year. The "normal" rivalries typically consisted of dissent between adjacent nations, an arms race of some sort, perhaps a fortification of borders, and maybe even an attack. In this sense, the cold war was both traditional and not at the same time.
As most people know, the cold was was a major nuclear arms race between America and the Soviet Union. This type of arms race leading up t a war is completely normal, but in this case the arms race pretty much was the war. It was this nuclear presence that set the cold war so far apart from others. Because the US and Russia were across the seas from each other, the fortifications occurred in other countries in Europe, which was very unusual. And instead or making defenses for their own country, each side simply pointed progressively more nuclear weapons at the other side. The long range of the weapons was what created and international panic: now even countries on the other side of the world were a serious threat.
The "war" was the result in a difference of two ideals, those of communism and those of capitalism. This kind of cause is normal, although the two sides were not. While sometimes fighting may break out on one side of the argument, the communists weren't even CLOSE to unified, which is highly unusual for a war, and especially ironic, as the point of communism is everyone working together for a better future.
While you could argue that actually engaging is battle is not necessary for war, it seems that a term like "contretemps" may better fit the cold war.
Note: I am not trying to say the cold war wasn't an issue; I understand that it was very close to being World War III, and quite possibly the end of life in Russia and America, but I'm not sure it fits the definition o a war.
The World Is a Big Bowl of Paperclips
WRITE a blog post in which you discuss, explain, muse upon the single most important thing you learned in Modern World History this year. It can be about history; it can be about the study of history; it can be about current events; it can be about yourself as a student, as a scholar, as a thinker, as a world citizen; it can be about other people. It can be anything.
I think the main thing I learned (if you're really forcing me to choose one..) is that history and the world is not just lots and lots of separate events that happen, and then they're done. They are all connected. Every single event in every corner of the world affects another part of the world, maybe in that same second, or maybe in a hundred years. Even more importantly, when we look at these events all together, and when we make connections, we can notice patterns. We can analyze the past in a way that makes sense, and is useful to know. If paper clips are events, the world is like what happens will you dump a million paper clips in one big bowl. They all connect. Whether we want them to or not, those little hooks latch onto each other and they all string together in complicated ways, and it would be impossible to unhook them all.
I don't think I'll ever meet someone who loves connections more than Ms. Pugliese, but really, connections are probably the most important lesson in history. I now know that we can't just make a decision as a nation, thinking that once it's done, we can just forget about it. It's going to be remembered for years to come, and it's going to be compared to other events in history that we might not even know about. It's going to matter.
Friday, June 4, 2010
Mmmm, Chocolate
There are so many things I learned this year, it's impossible to say the most important. I think it might be that all things history can be related, but can also be completely distinct. You can almost relate everything in history, but you can distinguish everything too. Studying history made me realize that in history, as in life, it all depends on how you look at something. It's kind of like chocolate covered pretzels. Can lump them all together, or, you can eat one pretzel at a time, making it individual. Let's look at revolutions. Sure, the French Rev, Industrial Rev, Algerian Rev, etc. are all revolutions. But when you study one in particular, you can see it's individuality and specificity emerge. Similarly with flags. So many countries show their nationalistic pride by waving their countries flags. They are all in the "flags" category, but each nation has it's own flag. Just like looking at a pretzel with individual clumps of chocolate. It's somewhat of a stretch, but I like to think about things in terms of food. Especially chocolate.
Thursday, June 3, 2010
Important Stuff
I can't choose one most important thing I learned this year, but I can certainly choose two.
The first, which I know I will continue to flash around for the rest of my school days, is nationalism. Nationalism is pretty much the main theme throughout the year, and can explain the majority of history. This word definitely make sit onto the "impressive terms that make you sound smart" list, including other just as large terms like globalization and stoichiometry (Okay, so stoichiometry isn't such a great word, because no one knows it, but its still fairly intelligent sounding). I will definitely keep nationalism in mind as I continue to study history.
The second thing, probably even more important, is that HISTORY CAN BE FUN. Not just interesting and informative, but actually enjoyable to learn. From the first time I had Humanities in fifth grade, I always hated it, especially the history part. Freshman year history was alright, but this year was actually fun. I liked coming to class, as odd as that may sound coming from a high schooler. I never looked at my schedule and groaned inwardly because I had history. NOT ONCE. This class was great, and I'm kind of looking forward to US History next year.
That's all. This is the end of my last blog post (or at least what would be my last blog post, if I was up-to-date on all of my homework).
The first, which I know I will continue to flash around for the rest of my school days, is nationalism. Nationalism is pretty much the main theme throughout the year, and can explain the majority of history. This word definitely make sit onto the "impressive terms that make you sound smart" list, including other just as large terms like globalization and stoichiometry (Okay, so stoichiometry isn't such a great word, because no one knows it, but its still fairly intelligent sounding). I will definitely keep nationalism in mind as I continue to study history.
The second thing, probably even more important, is that HISTORY CAN BE FUN. Not just interesting and informative, but actually enjoyable to learn. From the first time I had Humanities in fifth grade, I always hated it, especially the history part. Freshman year history was alright, but this year was actually fun. I liked coming to class, as odd as that may sound coming from a high schooler. I never looked at my schedule and groaned inwardly because I had history. NOT ONCE. This class was great, and I'm kind of looking forward to US History next year.
That's all. This is the end of my last blog post (or at least what would be my last blog post, if I was up-to-date on all of my homework).
Tuesday, May 25, 2010
La même histoire
Things I learned this year:
My system for taking notes has also changed; what good does it really do to write down every single thing that a presenter or film tells you? Will you truly use your notes? No, it is better to note the concepts or events that, given research and time, will get you further. Leads. Connections. Emotions. These are both ephemeral and necessary - they will not come back, and they can be the beginnings of new arguments.
So though we learned so much, it is unlikely that I will remember most of it in two years. I will remember, however, how to write a good argumentative essay in history, how to take notes, how to "gut" a paper, what to look for in primary documents, how to look at a situation in the larger scope of things. All in all, it has been a successful year.
- Happy people don't start revolutions. (Credits to Taylor)
- Most alliances are not lasting, and in some cases, not really trustworthy.
- There is usually a reason for something happening; societies don't stage upheavels because they are bored, fellow countries do not offer assistance because it is morally correct to do so. More often than not there is an ulterior motive.
- History is what we make of it, and the winner writes the story. Moral: be the winner.
My system for taking notes has also changed; what good does it really do to write down every single thing that a presenter or film tells you? Will you truly use your notes? No, it is better to note the concepts or events that, given research and time, will get you further. Leads. Connections. Emotions. These are both ephemeral and necessary - they will not come back, and they can be the beginnings of new arguments.
So though we learned so much, it is unlikely that I will remember most of it in two years. I will remember, however, how to write a good argumentative essay in history, how to take notes, how to "gut" a paper, what to look for in primary documents, how to look at a situation in the larger scope of things. All in all, it has been a successful year.
Hungary vs. Algeria
Both of these revolutions saw massive protests and other forms of uprisings against the government, who were both from another country. In Algeria, there were many boycotts against the French government, and in Hungary, there were huge protests against the Soviet puppet government. Also, the revolutions could both be considered failures. Though the Hungarian revolution worked for a few days, in the long run, Soviet troops did not leave Hungary until more than 30 years later. The Algerians were obliterated by the French and never really experienced much success in their respective revolutions. Clearly, both the Hungarian and Algerian revolutions have obvious connections.
Monday, May 24, 2010
UN Paragraph revision
Despite the disorganized website, it is clear that the UN is a very good organization, and will not do any harm. One could argue that they are inactive, and cannot exert any justice on the world, but it urns out they are just what we needed. The UN has made may decisions for a long time, consistently, and employs their own peace corps, made up of soldiers from many of the different countries who hold seats at the UN. It is these many countries that give the UN its strength: strength not only in numbers, but also in the wide varieties of perspectives and cultures offered. This large array of countries will help the UN be successful, as if one countries breaks the peace, like Germany did, there are many, many other countries to help stop them. The League of Nations did not work because it had so few countries, so that when Germany decided to take over Europe, it was difficult to do anything. The humanitarian missions of the UN are perhaps even better than their declarations. Before the UN, it was up to small, private organizations to deliver assistance to those in need, and floundering countries were virtually left on their own. Gaining help from a large, unified organization can only improve impoverished or war-torn areas.
Wednesday, May 19, 2010
Algeria and Iran
The Algerian Revolution and the Islamic Revolution in Iran were both ultimately unsuccessful because the governments that they created gave rise to political instability in a situation much like the one that the revolutions sought to free themselves from. After the Algerian Revolution, there was a constant struggle for power between political parties, and there still exists a huge divide between the French and the Algerians and Western culture and Islam. Similarly, Iran's Islamic Revolution produced a theocratic state and dictatorship, and people still live in constant fear of the government. In both revolutions, the idea of religion plays a huge role in determining the state of the new nation. In Algeria, the divide between religions makes it difficult to find unifying principles, and in Iran, the hopeful theocratic government slowly crumbled as the religion become intertwined with the declining political state. Although the Algerian revolution produced divisions within society that led to unrest, the Iranian Revolution seems to have created a tension between the government and its own people through ignorance of civil rights.
Tuesday, May 18, 2010
Questions and Answers
What exactly is a theocracy?
A theocracy is when a government is mainly based off of the nation's religion. Basically it is the opposite of what we have in the U.S., which is the separation of church and state. In some cases their ruler or leader is believed to have divine power, or a connection to the gods. In Iran's case, the government strictly follows the laws of the Koran.
What rights are Iranian citizens supposed to have?
It became clear to me through my research that there really isn't any regard to human rights in Iran, especially on the subject of protesting, and overall opposition to the government. One article states that "Privacy rights as well as the freedoms of press, speech, religion, assembly, and association are also limited by the government." Therefore, when looking at this question from a political standpoint, really the Iranian citizens do not have any real rights regarding protesting or freedom.
However, from a moral standpoint, we can answer this question differently. In my opinion, all humans should be guaranteed the right to freedom. This is not the case in Iran, but hopefully the UN or other groups will work to make it so.
THAILAND AND HUNGARY
Thesis Thailand: This is not an example of a successful revolution because it will probably not have long term effects.
Thesis Hungary: The Hungarian revolution was only successful depending on what time zone you look at. The success of the revolution fluctuates depending on the political, social, and economic states of the country.
The states of these two countries, as well as the basises for their respective revolutions are very similar. Both countries are unhappy with their governments, leading them to revolt. In Thailand, the monarchy is being questioned which led the country to political instability. Similarly in Hungary, the right wing nationalism has started to grow even though it is not represented in their government. Since the people of the Hungary are supporting something different than their government, they too have political instability. These shared political instabilities have caused economic failure in both countries. In Hungary, lies about the economy made by political leaders have led to major inflation and the general failure of the system. Economic growth in Thailand have also been halted because of protests in the center of the city. Finally, both theses have the commonality of neither of their revolutions sticking. In both countries, the revolutions seem to have immediate effects. but neither of them will stay long term.
Thesis Hungary: The Hungarian revolution was only successful depending on what time zone you look at. The success of the revolution fluctuates depending on the political, social, and economic states of the country.
The states of these two countries, as well as the basises for their respective revolutions are very similar. Both countries are unhappy with their governments, leading them to revolt. In Thailand, the monarchy is being questioned which led the country to political instability. Similarly in Hungary, the right wing nationalism has started to grow even though it is not represented in their government. Since the people of the Hungary are supporting something different than their government, they too have political instability. These shared political instabilities have caused economic failure in both countries. In Hungary, lies about the economy made by political leaders have led to major inflation and the general failure of the system. Economic growth in Thailand have also been halted because of protests in the center of the city. Finally, both theses have the commonality of neither of their revolutions sticking. In both countries, the revolutions seem to have immediate effects. but neither of them will stay long term.
Thailand and Algeria? intertwined
The connections between Thailand and Algeria are pretty great because both have the fact that their governments are in in political instability, and when the two sides argue one side massacres the other. Thailand has political instability because ever since it was changed to a democracy in 1973 there have been battling sides to decide what style of government they want. Thailand has massacres such as in the case of the failed government crackdown that killed 25 people and also recently on May 13 a protester that was a general he was shot in the head during an interview, so that massacres seem to be going on without stop because they cannot decide on what they want their government to be like. Algeria is in political instability because it has been fighting against France for independence back in the 50's and in the 90's they had the FIS and the GIA trying to seize control of Algeria, and recently in2005 the president of the GIA was arrested, and the GIA was declared unstable. Algeria had massacres such as when they had to fight against France for their independence and also when they had the GIA in 1998 massacred 50 innocent civilians.
Monday, May 17, 2010
Algeria vs. Iran
The revolutions in Algeria and Iran are very similar. Both revolutions have resulted in a government strongly influenced by religion. Religious extremist groups seized power in both cases. Both have suffered economically since their respective revolutions and are still struggling with poverty. Both have been unhappy with the elections of past leaders, and feel that their was fraud involved in the process. Both post revolution governments have attacked their citizens resulting in large death tolls; they show brutal retaliation. Overall, both revolutions were unsuccessful and worsened the state of their countries.
Similar Outcomes Through Specs
Although the revolutions in Iran and Thailand occurred in different eras, they are similar in many ways. Thailand and Iran both had unsuccessful revolutions. Although I know little of the revolution in Thailand, the group's thesis stated that it would be unlikely if it had long term effects. Similar in Iran, the government that was established by the revolutionaries is no longer in place today. There are similarities and differences throughout the SPECS categories of each country. In the scientific category, both countries involve weapons. Although in Iran, the focus of our ideas was that Iran is building nuclear weapons for the future. In Thailand, guns were used to take over the government, and they are not planning on creating new weapons. Both countries economies went down the drain. The U.S. instituted economic sanctions in an already poor country, making the economy plummet. In Thailand, the poor economy was caused by protests. The revolutions in Iran and Thailand are more similar than they are different with likely similar outcomes.
Hungary vs. Algeria
The Hungarian and Algerian revolutions were very similar in that they were both revolting against something foriegn. They were both backlash towards a foreign country taking them over and neither seem to have ended in greater stability for the country. Although they both now have their countries in their own hands, their economies have drooped and there is still a lot of political instability. They have major inflation as a result of their political unrest. They faught for their countries to be released from foriegn powers, but when they finally got their power it dissolved into economic and political instability. Algeria is ripped apart by religion and racial differences, while Hungary uses the Roma as scapegoats and fights against far right extremist nationalism.
One major difference between them is the religious aspect of the revolutions. In Algeria there is a large emphasis on Islam whereas in Hungary the revolution was purely political. Islam is based in a theocracy, so when the country revolts the religion gets involved, whereas in Hungary religion stays tucked away to make room for purely politial instability.
One major difference between them is the religious aspect of the revolutions. In Algeria there is a large emphasis on Islam whereas in Hungary the revolution was purely political. Islam is based in a theocracy, so when the country revolts the religion gets involved, whereas in Hungary religion stays tucked away to make room for purely politial instability.
Rebelutions
The Iranian and Algerian revolutions have many political and social similarities. Both revolutions include Islamic influences that caused tension and provoked internal violence.
In the Islamic Revolution, a revolution occurred to create a theocracy, or a religious based government. After gaining independence from France, Algeria went through several Islamist regimes, such as the FIS and the GIA (as mentioned in the timelines). Citizens were divided due t these regimes in both revolutions, which makes religious politics the root of both of these conflicts.
The circumstances in both revolutions show the strong correlation between the social, economic, and political aspects of a nation. When there are rapid political changes, the economy tends to plummet. When the economy plummets, citizens are unhappy and more likely to be driven to extremist groups and violence.
Iran vs. Algeria
SKIM the thesis, timeline, and SPECS table of the three other revolutionary groups. CHOOSE one of the revolutions and WRITE a comparison between it and the revolution you researched in class.
Thesis Iran: Iran's Islamic Revolution of 1979 was unsuccessful because its theocratic state was not maintained over time and its people live in fear of the now dictator-led government.
Thesis Algeria: The Algerian Revolution was not a success. Prior to the revolution, there were social problems involving race between the colonists and the native Algerians. The revolution failed to solve this problem and resulted in another. Now, there was a religious divide among Algerians as well as a racial one, due to the political instability and the growth of the Islamic Salvation Front.
There were many differences and similarities between both of these "Revolutions". First, the Algerian riots began around 1988, when twenty years earlier during 1963, the Secret Police in Iran were already trying to control the riots. Also, the Algerian Revolution lasted for a shorter time period, 20 years, (1980's - early 2000's) and the Islamic Revolution lasted for about 30 years (1960's - late 1990's). The dates of the Revolutions were different, but both of the Revolutions were looked as a failure. The Islamic Revolution could not maintain a theocratic state and the Algerian Revolution could not solve the social problems. The SPECS for both Revolutions are very different in both areas. The SPECS for Algeria were mainly about economic problems and inflation. The SPECS for Iran were mainly about the government and how the common people disagree with the way the government is ran. The problems Algeria had to deal with are more social and economic, while Iran had to deal with their government and fighting against political "corruption". Overall, the Algerian and Islamic Revolution mainly had differences in the causes, but had the same outcome: failure.
Thesis Iran: Iran's Islamic Revolution of 1979 was unsuccessful because its theocratic state was not maintained over time and its people live in fear of the now dictator-led government.
Thesis Algeria: The Algerian Revolution was not a success. Prior to the revolution, there were social problems involving race between the colonists and the native Algerians. The revolution failed to solve this problem and resulted in another. Now, there was a religious divide among Algerians as well as a racial one, due to the political instability and the growth of the Islamic Salvation Front.
There were many differences and similarities between both of these "Revolutions". First, the Algerian riots began around 1988, when twenty years earlier during 1963, the Secret Police in Iran were already trying to control the riots. Also, the Algerian Revolution lasted for a shorter time period, 20 years, (1980's - early 2000's) and the Islamic Revolution lasted for about 30 years (1960's - late 1990's). The dates of the Revolutions were different, but both of the Revolutions were looked as a failure. The Islamic Revolution could not maintain a theocratic state and the Algerian Revolution could not solve the social problems. The SPECS for both Revolutions are very different in both areas. The SPECS for Algeria were mainly about economic problems and inflation. The SPECS for Iran were mainly about the government and how the common people disagree with the way the government is ran. The problems Algeria had to deal with are more social and economic, while Iran had to deal with their government and fighting against political "corruption". Overall, the Algerian and Islamic Revolution mainly had differences in the causes, but had the same outcome: failure.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)