Showing posts with label late 20th revs - 1. Show all posts
Showing posts with label late 20th revs - 1. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Is This Iran?

a.) Questions:

- Why did the Iranian government wish to put down the protesters?
- What did they hope to gain from violence? Did they think it would help them gain popularity?
- Why would the "crackdown" "heighten nuclear concerns?" Does the fact that they are dangerous one way make it more likely they are dangerous in another?
- What evidence is there for a nuclear program in Iran?
- Why is it usually the youth that protests against injustices, even when the older generation experiences a dramatic change as well?
- The government attempted to restrict information getting out- is this relatively easy to do in foreign countries compared with the US?
- How much of Iran actually gets internet and cellphone coverage?
- What actually happens when you get arrested in Iran?
- How does the Iranian justice system work?
- Was the vote actually rigged?
- Were the protests actually as peaceful as they are said to be?

b.) Connections:

- Restriction of information: we haven't studied it, but this is very similar to what is currently going on in China, and what has traditionally gone on in isolationist countries for centuries.
- Fast, brutal suppression very similar to that of the Hungarian revolution.
- Also, protesters were peaceful, young students.
- People protesting about lack of control over their own government

c.) Gut Reaction

The comics strip was pretty shocking. Over here in my isolated little world, I had no idea how intense an unprovoked attack like this could be. The strip was almost graphic, but left just enough to the imagination for the result to be rather horrifying. I know that people everywhere are fighting for freedom to choose their won government, but I did not realize how violently these governments are willing to respond to peaceful protests.

Reaction to Zahra's Paradise

For homework we read a comic strip named Zahra's Paradise. The strip was a political cartoon drawn by a two semi anonymous authors named Amir who is an Iranian-American activist and Khalil who is an Arab artist from northern Africa. The cartoon is mostly about the harsh reaction of the Iranian government towards Iranian citizens who protested the results of the last election (it is widely believed that the election was rigged and that the election was a fraud). My first reaction to the cartoon was that it was very dark. The thought of injured citizens being dragged out of hospitals to be beaten by government paid guards is very scary. Also, I sympathized with the protesters being dragged out of the hospital more than with the mother looking for her lost son. Overall, the cartoon was very telling about the Iranian government and has given me a bias against Amadinejad despite not knowing much about him. I was also able to make several connections to other history after reading the cartoon. I connected Freedom square and Tienanmen Square because they both were (coincidentally?) squares, as well as spots for political protest that resulted in bloodshed and government backlash. I connected the retaliation of the revolutionary guards to the retaliation of the Soviets against the Hungarians in the Hungarian revolution because both were swift and excessive.

After reading the cartoon I wondered:

.What was so bad about the policies of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad?

.Was there a retaliation by the protesters against the revolutionary guards?How Long did the violence last?

.Where did they take the injured protesters?

Tuesday, May 11, 2010

Questions:
-How reliable was this story?
-How is this related to the Islamic Revolution from 1979?
-Why did the publisher use this medium? How did it affect the telling of the story?

Connections:
-The Gulag/Stalin
-the Hungarian Revolution
-Propaganda by the Nazi's or just Propaganda in general

Gut reaction:
-The power of backlash to suppression is huge and is seen again and again in all the things we've studied.
-Change targets the younger generations
-revolutionaries are supposedly peaceful but how much of that is relative? Relatively peaceful does not equal truely peaceful.

Are My Questions as UpFront as you would like them to be?

Questions

-In Iran is the country really in that bad of a chaotic state?
-Should we really be using Nuclear power for power?
-Who is Obama going to pick?

Connections
-The North Korea story related to my first semester project
-Disaster to the ancient times

Gut reaction

I really do not think Iran is in this bad of a situation
I also think that North Korea needs to be watched more closely

Monday, May 10, 2010

To say the least, Iran is having trouble

What exactly is the state of Iran? I think it will be hard to find an unbiased source to this question, but we can't base everything off the news and this comic.
I'd like to know more about the Islamic Revolution of 1979

During the Hungarian Revolution, it was also the young people that wanted change and started the protests.
Censorship in general can be connected to a lot of countries, like China nowadays, or communist Russia. Also the book-banning in India.
Not knowing where people are being sent when they are arrested: like the Gulag. Also this could relate to the Holocaust and the concentration camps because I think the rest of Germany was in the dark a little bit about where the Jews were actually being sent (Since a lot of the camps were far away or in Poland)

I was kind of shocked to see this comic. I think it's a very shocking topic in general, and I have a lot of sympathy for the people living in Iran (especially in the hospitals! How awful!) However I think it was mainly very shocking to me seeing the information presented this way. I don't read political comics or things like this, so this was the first time I'd seen something like this. It makes me wonder why the artists didn't just present it like a normal article, but this was certainly very powerful and shocking, and if this is what they were going for, then it worked.

Zahra's Paradise

a.) questions/leads

  • Is this publisher of this article anonymous? How does she maintain her safety?
  • Islamic Revolution of 1979
  • how gov't's crackdown could relate to its nuclear program


b.) connections

  • The little boy was obviously affected by propaganda, this is similar to the youth in Germany being indoctrinated into the Nazi party. The youth are more easily swayed than older generations.
  • ''being arrested can mean disappearing altogether" - like Stalin's Gulag
c.) gut reactions

  • scared
  • the comic makes the Iranian protest more personal, I feel her desperation, easier to empathize
Questions/Leads
1. How much of this is actually propaganda?
2. What did Ahmedinajad do that was so bad, and how do they know Mousavi will be better?
3. Islamic Revolution of 1979

Connections
Extremist groups going after youth population because they are easily swayed


Gut Reaction
Iran is in too deep trouble. I don't think the United States should go worrying about Iran because there are enough problems here already.

Is this actually happening to Iran?

READ the cover story ("Is This Iran?") from the most recent Upfront. Make a list of a.) questions/leads the article raises for you, b.) connections you can make to other areas of history, and c.) your gut reactions. POST this list to the blog.

Questions:

- Is this what is actually happening in Iran right now, or is it a form of propaganda?
- How reliable are this person's sources?
- Since it's a comic, are there any real pictures to prove this is all actually happening?

Connections:

Violence is like the Taliban fighting the government.
The Nazi's fighting the people who want their rights of freedom.
Hungarian Revolution: The protests defeated by violence from the government.

"Gut Reactions":

The comic and article might be exaggerated or understated because this person's resources may not be completely accurate. If it was all true, then I believe that the people of Iran need some type of liberation. A type of revolution would be ideal, but the "rebels" hardly have the resources and numbers to defeat the government itself. They all want peace and freedom, but they don't have the solution to achieve it yet. Hopefully, they will find some solution soon without too many young teenagers having to perish.

What's up with Iran?

Questions:
-What do the Iranian people want?
-If the violence was so bad, why didn't outside nations intervene?
-Where's the UN?

Connections:
-Russian Revolution
-Stalin's Gulag/secret police
-Night of the Broken Glass
-political/social motif: secular versus religious
-Great Terror (random deaths and arrests)

Gut:
-this scene shows the flaws that fascism and communism both had
-terror and secret arrests are from the government, which is frightening to the public
-radical change in younger Iranian population's political mindset: too much radical change?
-the election was the start of a potential revolution, but it was smashed by terror and secret police forces - this is strikingly similar to Soviet communism (trying to prevent the domino effect)

Personally I prefer Spiderman as far as comics are concerned...

1. If these men live in America, how do they have so much insight into the revolutions in Iran? Assuming that their knowledge goes beyond what they hear on the news. Especially if Internet access is being limited. What is the controversy surrounding last summer's election? What happened in the Islamic Revolution? What exactly is a theocracy? Why is internet access being restricted and what are people doing to get around it (if anything)? is the Iranian government doing anything about the comic?

2. Hungarian Revolution- protests slammed by the government. China earlier this year- limitation on the Internet. Animal Farm- similar to the comic by using writing and art to express opinions on what's going on in the world without saying it out right. Hungarian reporters telling outsiders their stories- the comic comes from America, not Iran so that the whole world can know whats going on.

3. I feel like a revolution so harsh should have been given more space on the page. The article provides little background information on what's going on and only a small paragraph on the actual protests. If the world is really to be told about what's going on, then there should be more information. Now I feel confused as to why the government is cracking down so hard on the student protesters and why they would cut down Internet use. Without help from the article, I am left to assume that it is just because the government is scared of losing control, which would actually make a lot of sense...

Finding Zahra

Questions/Leads:
  • What was the controversy over the presidential elections? Who was Mahmoud Ahmadinejad before he became president? What are his policies?
  • Is there something unique about the cemetery "Zahra's Paradise" and why is this well suited to the story? Are many revolutionaries buried here?
  • What happened in the Islamic Revolution and how does it tie in with the Iran of today?
  • What is the Freedom Square? Is the implied governmental promise more than tacit?
  • What is the Revolutionary Guard, a guard made up of revolutionaries or guards against revolutionaries?
Connections:
  • Disappearing when arrested - similar to Nazis with concentration camps, the Stasi with political prisoners, or USSR with the gulag.
  • Restrictions on the Internet - censorship/propaganda, similar to China hiding searches about Tibet, and book burnings conducted by the Nazis
  • Hospital scene - like during a war, but this is supposedly a country at peace
Gut Reactions: I feel for the revolutionaries that were suppressed, while I my feelings for the government are not so kindly. Why?
  • The first sentence that a child (too young to respond intelligently to a question) will regurgitate is "The nation would rather perish than accept ignominy." From the way the comic went following that caption, it seems that it will both perish AND accept ignominy.
  • The government seems to be ignoring the human side of their people - they will remove injured revolutionaries to be incarcerated while other citizens look on in shock and families still search for lost loved ones. If they are not considering that their actions will bring grief and desire to rise up, then they intend to suppress the people by means of fear and force.
  • In the article, the protests by the revolutionaries are described as peaceful, while the government responds with violence. It is as if they were trying to kill a fly with a sledgehammer. This defensiveness says to me that the government is suspect and feels that it has something to hide or protect.

Iranian Comic

A) What rights are Iranian citizen supposed to have? (Is freedom to peacefully assemble one of them?) What happens to the people that get arrested? What other events have the government successfully covered up? How does the government justify reacting so violently to a protest? Isn't the freedom square a bit ironic?

B) The obvious connection here is with the Hungarian Revolution. Although in this case another country is not openly controlling Iran, the country is facing bitterly harsh punishment for protesting for their rights. There is the same sense of the stronger power reacting with much more force than necessary, and crushing any opposition to avoid larger revolutions in the future.

C) My gut reaction is that something must be done to free Iran from this kind of dictatorship. But the question is, what? The US is already way too involved in other countries, but the people of Iran definitely cannot do this themselves. Their government is way too controlling and veiled for them to find a way to peacefully create a happy society. They aren't strong enough as an unorganized mob to fight the government, and that would probably only end in chaos anyway. I feel like this situation is becoming hopeless, but I keep wanting to find an answer.

Is This Iran?

What about Mahmoud Ahmadinejad made so many people protest about unfairness?
How does the government operate? To what extent does it suppress its people?
How do Iranians generally feel about the government?

Stalin's NKVD and the Gulag
Robespierre and the Reign of Terror
German fascism and the concentration camps
Bengali nationalists during the Bangladesh Liberation War

From all that I understand, it seems like the police shooting of protestors was not completely unnecessary and unjust but a vicious act against human rights in general. First, in a society that agrees to operate under a democracy, at the very least, people deserve the right to have a say in their leaders, free of the blatant fraud committed during last June's election. In addition, people were protesting, but the police immediately killed many in order to break up the protests. It seems like they are controlling people with nothing more than brute force and scaring the Iranian people into submission. As illustrated (no pun intended) by the cartoon, there are people who still fight for their rights but do so in secret. It seems like something has to change; people realizing that they are being cheated by their own government, peace can never be achieved.