Friday, March 12, 2010

Animal Farm

Though I cant say that I am particularly fond of the novel, I have to admit that Animal Farm does provide a point of view of the Russia Revolution that is hard to come by. Instead of trying to cover up and give reasons for Stalin's actions like most documents from that era in Russian history tend to do, Orwell presents the series of events through an unbiased point of view. After finding the not so subtly hidden allegory between real life historical figures and the pigs in Animal Farm, its easy to find parallels between the story and the real events. Right from the beginning we can see that Old Major is a combination of Lenin and Marx because he sparks the idea of the Animal Farm and a separate and superior animal WORKER race (making him Marx), starts the revolution, and then shortly dies (making him Lenin). Then, in Chapters 4-6, it becomes clear that Napoleon and Snowball represent Stalin and Trotsky. Snowball shows characteristics of Trotsky like the ability to persuade people through words like Trotsky could do with pictures. Napoleon is more quiet and cunning like Stalin was. At the end of chapter 5, he shows Stalin like tendencies when he sends his secret band of puppies (suspiciously similar to the NKVD) after Snowball and then persuades everyone that Snowball is bad, just like Stalin did with Trotsky. The rest of the story seems to follow history as it is showing the pigs giving themselves more and more power, all the while justifying it by convincing everyone that it is the right thing to do. The animals on the farm have no ability to say their actual opinions, just like the people who did not have power had no voice in the Communist movement. I think that in the rest of the story, we will be able to see that the more the pigs give themselves power, the more they will find themselves becoming the things they hate--the humans.

I think that Orwell wrote this book to show what the Communist movement looked like from the outside. All documents from that era are biased towards Stalin, because he would have killed them if they weren't. Animal Farm provides an unbiased point of view of the events during that time in history, but it also makes the lesson easier to grasp. It's much easier to figure that what happens in the book is bad when reading it about animals because it makes the subject lighter.

Animal Farm

The comparison I see is that the nine dogs that were the Cheka which were the fighting group for Stalin at the time and that is exactly like what Napoleon did because at first he just secretly took the puppies away because he wanted to teach them himself, but we would find out that he was not teaching them but in actuality he was building them to be fighting killing machines that would only serve the Napoleon and were completely loyal to only him. As shown Napoleon would use these dogs as Stalin used the Cheka to silence ones that opposed him and people who were against the revolution, Napoleon used the dogs to show that you could not act against Snowball and get away with it as in the case of Snowball because he knew the animals would listen to him because he was very well spoken and he saw farm was in agreement with Snowball so he used his influence on the dogs to silence the opposition and thus he was the only leader left it was his farm now because there was no one left to oppose him, and he got to that place because of the dogs. Stalin also used Cheka to get rid of Trotsky supporters so only his voice would be heard.

Thursday, March 11, 2010

Animalism... communism?

I definitely think that Animal Farm is an allegory to communism, mainly because of the clear representations of different people in Russian communism, and also because of the complete political control that is under the pretense of "All animals created equal." We said in class that Major was Marx, and that Napoleon was Stalin. I think these are very fitting comparisons. Major was the one to initiate it all, while Napoleon is very violent and wants to be in control of everything. He also steps up to be the new leader, like Stalin did. I also think that Animal Farm relates to communism because of the absolute control the leaders, Napoleon and Snowball, each have. Snowball and Napoleon come up with the seven commandments, and make every animal memorize them. If the animals cannot learn to read everything, they must be able to read the seven commandments, or at least know them. Also, Snowball and Napoleon have convinced everyone that the apples and milk are only for the pigs, because pigs need nourishment for their minds since they are the smartest. The "government" or leaders own everything, just like in Russian communism. Although the seventh commandment clearly states "All animals are equal", we can see that this is not at all the case, which is why Animal Farm is an allegory to Russian Communism.

Animal Farm and YOU

Animal farm can be referenced to many historic points if you really go in depth with it. Since we've most recently discussed Stalin it's easy to relate him to Napoleon and Trotsky definetly can be related to Snowball. Because George Orwell is familiar with Russian Communism, the book Animal Farm can be directly related to the revolution that took place. Not only does it relate to the Communist era but it has shades of revolution ideas. The animals on the farm are represented as the working class. Because they feel below the social level they revolt against the humans. This has some familiarity to the French Revolution and how the 3rd estate felt like they weren't be represented they revolted.

Animal Farm

Animal Farm could be an allegory for many different political things, but it is easiest to see the ties between it and Russian communism. As we decided, Major was a mixture of Marx and Lenin, and Napoleon is Stalin. I think that Snowball is definitely meant to be Trotsky, while Squealer is most likely one of Stalin's upper-class officials. I am fairly certain that George Orwell (actually Eric Blair) intended for Animal Farm to be an allegory for Russian Communism, especially because he was alive during the Russian revolution and rise of the communist regime. Animal Farm is similar to the French Revolution as well, but it probably bears many similarities to most revolutions, as it is the tale of the oppressed overcoming the oppressors, the ideal of any revolt.

Animal Farm and History

The figures in George Orwell's Animal Farm are obvious representations of the communism, fascism, and historical revolution. The animals of the farm signify the working class who feel slaved and exploited by higher authorities (Mr. Jones). The Russian working class (led by the Bolsheviks) rose up and usurped the Tsar and restored a completely new order: socialism. The French 3rd estate, along with the vast majority of the peasant class in France, impeached Louis XVI and replaced the monarchy with the Committee of public safety. Fascist Germany, after creating a somewhat stable government, elected Jews as scapegoats, identical to the animals on the far, except the animals chose humans. The government/revolution models expressed through the book clearly represent the uprisings of the Communist Era, including fascism and socialism.

As the animals gain more of an understanding for their social rules and laws, the pigs start to realize their power and advantage over their "citizens." Soon enough, the pigs start to save extra rations for themselves and change laws without consent from the public. Better yet, they justify their injustices. This series of events directly represents how Hitler, Stalin, and Robespierre exploited their own power. Hitler led Germans into antagonizing Jews, and justified it as a means of safety and prosperity for Germany. Stalin, after rising to power during a time of newly-found communism, organized secret polices to purge any suspicious people/groups whom he felt opposed him. Robespierre and the Committee of Public Safety developed themselves into a centralized government group with supreme power, creating new laws and killing thousands of people. The essential similarity between these three regimes and Animal Farm is this: all of these radical regimes became the very thing they sought to destroy. They sought to destroy monarchy and lack of representation. Are their new regimes any different? The answer is no, and that contradiction in itself led to each of their collapses.

Animal Farm... connections

Animal Farm started out with Manor Farm, a peaceful working farm owned and run by Mr. Jones. The main animals on the farm are: Old Major, Napoleon, Snowball, Squealer (the pigs,) Boxer and Clover (work horses,) Mollie (a silly mare,) Muriel (a goat,) Benjamin (a donkey,) Moses (a sneaky raven.) The animals revolted against Mr. Jones because of the persuasive words of Old Major. Old Major died, and the pigs took it upon their responsibility to take control. Snowball and Napoleon in particular stepped up as leaders. However, they disagreed on everything. Napoleon kept sneaking around, keeping secrets, and seemed to be up to no good. Up to this point, the animals were fairly considered equal, besides being under command of the pigs. There was talk going around about building a windmill. Snowball initiated the idea, while Napoleon strongly opposed it. When the animals were going to vote with Snowball in favor of building the windmill, Napoleon called out puppies he had raised in secret to attack Snowball. Fearing his life, he ran away, barely escaping. Later on, Napoleon decides to build the windmill, and claims that the plans were all of his, and were stolen by Snowball. Boxer, who is slaving away on the windmill (waking up early, working during the night) recieves no compensation or rewards for his devout loyalty. Although the pigs do not usually do any physical labor, the pigs received special treatment. They slept in the farmhouse on beds, sat on raised platforms during meeting, and slept in, to name a few. Although many of these privileges were against the original commandments, Squealer was able to convince all the animals that it was all in their heads. Along with Squealer's persuasive speeches, the vicious growling dogs helped the animals decision to keep quiet.
The story ties into history in several aspects. First, the farm was like communism. Everybody started out relatively equal, but soon, the elite leaders received subtle advantages. For example, the animals started out having the right to vote. Later on, Napoleon and his committee of piggies make all the decisions. Although in communism, everything is supposed to be equal, only the leaders make important decisions. The vicious dogs are like the Cheka. They were a secret group that kept the pigs and the communist leaders in power. Napoleon, like Stalin, is trying to purge anybody who might come to power. Napoleon got rid of Snowball like Stalin got rid of Trotsky. Animal Farm is also similar to fascism. In fascism, the government completely controls civilians' lives. In Animal Farm, the pigs assign each animal jobs and a strict schedule every week. Animal Farm is also like the situation in France before the French Revolution. The nationalistic revolters took pride in their revolutionary actions, and The Marseillaise was their "pump up" song. The animals sing Beasts of England to get themselves excited about the Animal Farm, and encourage them to be nationalistic.
Orwell's motivation was to get his beliefs about the government out without using actual names. Had he used real names, he would have been strictly reprimanded. Orwell is venting about the situation, and to us it's obvious he is telling the story of the government.